SALT LAKE CITY, UT – Utah State Senators passed a controversial bill last week which would allow public schools the option of offering abstinence-only sex education curricula or none at all. The bill passed by a vote of 19-10, split heavily along party lines. If adopted, the policy would be the most restrictive in the U.S.
If signed into law by Gov. Gary Herbert, the measure will bar Utah public school teachers from talking with students about homosexuality and other forms of sexuality—excluding abstinence—before marriage. It will also prevent public schools from teaching students about the use of contraceptives as a means of preventing pregnancy and sexually transmitted diseases (STDs) and infections.
“This just clarifies we’ll have an abstinence- only curriculum or a nothing curriculum,” Sen. Margaret Dayton (R-Orem), the bill’s sponsor told the Deseret News. Herbert, a Republican, has not publically offered support or opposition to the measure. A race for re-election this year might push the governor to support this conservative bill in this ultra-Red state.
Supporters of the “Don’t Gay, Don’t Condom” bill argue that sex-ed is best left to the parents, rather than public schools. The Beehive State presently requires that students enroll in sexual education classes only if their parents choose to allow it.
“To replace the parent in the school setting, among people who we have no idea what their morals are, we have no ideas what their values are, yet we turn our children over to them to instruct them in the most sensitive sexual activities in their lives, I think is wrongheaded,” Sen. Stuart Reid (R-Ogden), told the Salt Lake Tribune.
Across the aisle, Democratic lawmakers said that the restrictive measure will leave students at greater risk for STDs, pregnancy, and abortions. They argued that not all parents have the skills or temperament to keep their children informed about the consequences of sexual activity and its potentially-harmful effects.
“We’ve been discussing this as if every child has the benefit of two loving and caring parents who are ready to have a conversation about appropriate sexual activity, and I’m here to tell you that’s just not the case,” Sen. Ross Romero (D-Salt Lake City) told the Salt Lake Tribune.
A study published recently in the Archives of Pediatric and Adolescent Medicine reported that those states that require comprehensive, all-encompassing sexual education courses have lower teen birth rates. The study also found that the impact of sex-ed programs may be offset by factors including race, religion, income levels, and state abortion regulations.