They Just Do One Person Shows
By Warren Day
Whether it be the world premiere of a new comedy, as they will do in July with Stuf by Michael McKeever, or the regional premiere of a recent Tony-winning drama, as in God of Carnage by Yasmina Reza this past May, the professional Caldwell Theatre in Boca Raton presents engrossing productions that usually can’t be found anywhere else in Florida.
Such was the case the first week in June, when they presented the legendary actor Ed Asner in FDR by Dore Schary.
Legendary is not too strong a word for this veteran actor of stage, screen and, especially, television, who has won seven Emmys and five Golden Globes, and was recently the lead voice actor in the Academy Award Best Animated Feature Up.
At the age of 81, most actors have retired by necessity, but Mr. Asner has been making appearances around the country playing our 32nd president of the United States in a demanding and grueling one-man show.
Over the last couple of decades, it’s been something of a phenomenon to have performers travel in one-person productions. Sometimes these shows are an evening recap of their careers, as Lena Horne did for several years and which Elaine Stitch is still doing. Other times they are fictional works where the sole actor plays all the parts, as Lily Tomlin did in The Search for Intelligent Life in the Universe.
Most often, these shows consist of a single actor playing a famous person, i.e., Henry Fonda as the lawyer Clarence Darrow, or Tovah Feldshuh as either Golda Mier or Talluhah Bankhead (now there’s a stretch for you).
These live performances can be great theater when the actor and the historical person seem a natural fit for each other, as with Hal Holbrook in Mark Twain Tonight. Other times, all the magical ingredients can seem to be there, as when Vincent Price played Oscar Wilde, but actually end up offering a rather bland and predictable evening, something the real Mr. Wilde never did.
As Roosevelt, Ed Asner falls somewhere between success and failure. He doesn’t fit FDR in age, looks, or accent; neither does he have that patrician air that was so much a part of this upperclass, but populist, president.
The fact that his performance works as well as it does is a tribute to his acting chops, as when he captures the joy in being able to stand for a few seconds without his canes (FDR had polio), or the believable and quick transition to anguish he makes at another point. Another plus is that Mr. Asner’s admiration for the President who led us through the depression and World War II shines through and is contagious. The audience obviously had great admiration for Ed Asner, and gave him a standing ovation at the end, but I think that was more for what Roosevelt had done in real life and for what Asner had done in other parts.

Photo: Award Winning actor, Ed Asner, will be appearing in FDR as President
Roosevelt at the Caldwell Theatre
Whether it be the world premiere of a
new comedy, as they will do in July
with Stuf by Michael McKeever, or the
regional premiere of a recent Tony-winning
drama, as in God of Carnage by
Yasmina Reza this past May, the professional
Caldwell Theatre in Boca Raton
presents engrossing productions that
usually can’t be found anywhere else in
Florida.
Such was the case the first week in
June, when they presented the legendary
actor Ed Asner in FDR by Dore Schary.
Legendary is not too strong a word for
this veteran actor of stage, screen and,
especially, television, who has won seven
Emmys and five Golden Globes, and was
recently the lead voice actor in the
Academy Award Best Animated Feature
Up.
At the age of 81, most actors have
retired by necessity, but Mr. Asner has
been making appearances around the
country playing our 32nd president of
the United States in a demanding and
grueling one-man show.
Over the last couple of decades, it’s
been something of a phenomenon to
have performers travel in one-person
productions. Sometimes these shows are
an evening recap of their careers, as
Lena Horne did for several years and
which Elaine Stitch is still doing. Other
times they are fictional works where the
sole actor plays all the parts, as Lily
Tomlin did in The Search for Intelligent
Life in the Universe.
Most often, these shows consist of a
single actor playing a famous person,
i.e., Henry Fonda as the lawyer Clarence
Darrow, or Tovah Feldshuh as either
Golda Mier or Talluhah Bankhead (now
there’s a stretch for you).
These live performances can be great
theater when the actor and the historical
person seem a natural fit for each other,
as with Hal Holbrook in Mark Twain
Tonight. Other times, all the magical
ingredients can seem to be there, as
when Vincent Price played Oscar Wilde,
but actually end up offering a rather
bland and predictable evening, something
the real Mr. Wilde never did.
As Roosevelt, Ed Asner falls somewhere
between success and failure. He
doesn’t fit FDR in age, looks, or accent;
neither does he have that patrician air
that was so much a part of this upperclass,
but populist, president.
The fact that his performance works
as well as it does is a tribute to his acting
chops, as when he captures the joy in
being able to stand for
a few seconds without
his canes (FDR had
polio), or the believable
and quick transition
to anguish he
makes at another
point. Another plus
is that Mr. Asner’s
admiration for the
President who led us
through the depression
and World War II
shines through and is
contagious. The audience
obviously had
great admiration for
Ed Asner, and gave
him a standing ovation
at the end, but I
think that was more
for what Roosevelt
had done in real life
and for what Asner
had done in other
parts.