Â
More countries around the world now allow gay marriage, so it seems as though same-sex marriage is becoming a more accepted phenomenon. But do young LGBTQ people see it as an option? According to books for children and young adults (“YAsâ€), the answer is “no.†Robin Reardon, who has written several YA novels with gay male protagonists, has her main character in “A Secret Edge,†Jason, consider gay marriage.
He thinks, “I’ve never given [marriage] much thought before. But now–I guess it’s out of the question for me. I mean, you hear about two guys getting married, sort of, but it seems a little far-fetched to me. And suddenly a lot of things most people take for granted seem a little far-fetched for me. Living with someone you love. Having kids.†Jason’s sad ponderings might make a reader pity gay people and their limited opportunities for a happy and fulfilling romantic relationship. Jason’s uncle, who raised him, is sorely disappointed when he learns that his nephew is gay. He thinks, “No one should have to live like that. He’ll be hated, ostracized.
He won’t be able to marry or have children.†Like Jason’s uncle, Liza’s father in Nancy Garden’s “Annie on My Mind†worries about what being gay will mean for his daughter. Although not as disgusted by her lesbianism as some of her teachers are, Liza’s father says that he doesn’t want this for her, because it will mean she can never marry or have children. In Maureen Johnston’s “The Bermudez Triangle,†Avery thinks about her girlfriend, “’What if Mel wanted to get married and have a commitment ceremony and play Ani DiFranco and k.d. lang songs and have cats as bridesmaids?’ That would be great for Mel, but it just wasn’t something Avery could picture.
The thought scared her. A lot.â€W hile it’s great to see that there’s some recognition that there are opportunities for gay couples to show their commitment to one another, this passage stereotypically mocks what lesbians are like (cat-mad avid Ani DeFrancolisteners) and also suggests that the idea of a ceremony isn’t too appealing. If you look at preeminent queer writer for children Lesléa Newman’s oeuvre of picture books (including “Mommy, Mama, and Me,†“Daddy, Papa, and Me,†and “Heather Has Two Mommiesâ€), you won’t find any marriages. Similarly, Michael Willhoite’s “Daddy’s Roommateâ€â€”which relies on the euphemism “roommate†rather than employing “boyfriend,†“partner,†or, heaven forbid, “husbandâ€â€”and Hedi Argent’s “Josh and Jaz Have Three Mums,†don’t seem to consider the possibility that the two mothers or two fathers could actually be wife-and-wife or husband-and-husband.
One of the few picture books to feature gay marriage is Ken Setterington’s “Mom and Mum are Getting Married.†The story here is about how Mom and Mum just want a small ceremony while their daughter Rosie wants to be the flower girl in a big event. It’s a refreshing change to see a picture book normalize gay marriage and show a gay couple making a legal commitment. One could argue that authors reflect society within their writing and if young people are taught to believe that marriage is not an option for gay people, there is actually little incentive for a government’s policies to change. Regardless of whether it’s up to the authors or the politicians to take the first step, the solution is clear: legalize gay marriage and portray it in books for children and young adults. It needn’t be “out of the question†any more.
B.J. Epstein is a lecturer in literature and translation at the University of East Anglia (United Kingdom), where she specializes in children’s literature, queer literature, and literary translation.
Â
Â
]]>When Mitt Romney selected a gay man, Richard Grenell, as his Foreign Policy and National Security Spokesman, the Log Cabin Republicans, GOProud, and LGBT conservatives everywhere hailed this appointment as proof that Romney, in his heart, was a fair man who will do right by the gay community.
But it took only ten days for Grenell to be gone, and Romney’s anti-gay bona fides to be stronger than ever. Grenell’s decision to leave the Romney presidential campaign came after a busy week of foreign policy news. While Grenell was allowed to listen in on a key press call on foreign policy, the New York Times reported that he was neither introduced at the beginning of the call, nor allowed to speak during the conversation.
Apparently, this humiliation was too much for Grenell, appointed to a position where relationships with reporters are vital to success. Grenell’s letter of resignation thanked Romney “for his belief in me and my abilities and his clear message to me that being openly gay was a non-issue for him and his team,†and placed the blame for his departure on “the hyper-partisan discussion of personal issues.
Furious voices on the right came fast to condemn Romney when he initially selected Grenell, the loudest being Bryan Fischer of the American Family Association. After Fischer took credit for Grenell’s resignation, his directive to Romney going forward was unequivocal: “I will flat-out guarantee you Romney is not going to make this mistake again. There is no way in the world that Mitt Romney is going to put a homosexual activist in any position of importance in his campaign.†At no point during the Grenell affair did Romney publicly speak out against the ugly voices of bigotry coming from the right. That would have taken conviction and leadership.
In his statement of regret over Grenell’s resignation, Romney’s language contained a dog whistle to the right to reassure them that he remains one of them: “We select people not based upon their ethnicity or their ‘sexual preference’…†(to be read as a choice and changeable), avoiding the accurate “sexual orientation†(derided by the right for its intrinsic and unchangeable connotation). What does all this mean for the November election? LGBT voters are a small constituency, representing perhaps five percent of the voting population.
But a growing number of young heterosexuals see LGBT equality as the civil rights issue of our time. The Grenell debacle has reminded young voters, as well as those with gay loved ones, that a Romney presidency, ruled by the right, will reverse the forward trajectory of LGBT equality in America. After his victory, an emboldened Bryan Fischer told The Nation magazine that candidate Romney must commit to other anti-gay measures, including vetoing the Employment Non-Discrimination Act (ENDA) if it reaches his desk.
During his failed U.S. Senate run in 1994, Romney made a commitment to Massachusetts’ Log Cabin Republicans to co-sponsor ENDA at the federal level. But in 2007 Romney told Tim Russert on “Meet The Press†that he would not support ENDA at the federal level.
When Russert challenged this about face, Romney was unfazed: “Oh, Tim, if you’re looking to someone who’s never changed any positions on any policies, then I’m not your guy.†Now there’s a solid Romney conviction.
Marc Paige is a writer, LGBT rights activist, and HIV/AIDS prevention educator. He can be reached at marcpaige@ msn.com. ]]>
Recently, I was speaking to a Gay Studies class at Florida International University, my alma mater. A student asked me which one LGBT law I would change if I were empowered to do so. I’m sure most expected me to say I’d legalize gay marriage, the continued hot topic of the gay community.
Instead I answered with something that was not only unexpected, but for many, a topic they didn’t realize existed. I said I would overturn the federal ban on gay men donating blood.
Since 1985, gay men have not been able to legally donate blood in the United States. This policy was instituted by our government in the earliest, most fearful days of the AIDS epidemic. When so little was known about the disease, reactionary officials instituted the ban as a way to ensure the nation’s blood supply would remain “clean.â€
The gay rights movement has many fields of battle. In recent months, Congress has repealed “Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell,†President Obama signed a bill extending hate crime protections to sexual orientation, and more and more states allow same-sex marriage.
But to our list of equality issues, we should immediately add overturning a ridiculous Federal policy which jeopardizes the well-being of each of us. We should fight to overturn the Federal ban on gay men (“MSMs,†or men who have sex with men) donating blood.
The good news is that there is a growing movement afoot in Washington, DC to do it. Under the leadership of U.S. Sen. John Kerry (D-MA) and U.S. Rep. Mike Quigley (D-IL), the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) has outlined concrete steps toward ending the outdated, discriminatory lifetime ban on gay and bisexual men from donating blood.
In 2010, a group of 18 U.S. Senators led by Massachusetts’s Kerry penned a letter to FDA officials calling for an end to an “outdated, medically and scientifically unsound†policy.
Most Americans—including many gays—do not even realize the ban is still in place. The FIU gay issues class students I addressed were well-versed in gay marriage, bullying, AIDS awareness, and the usual gay rights issues. But when I brought up the blood ban, very few of the people in attendance knew it existed.
Obviously, thanks to modern science, we now know much more about the spread of HIV and AIDS than we did in 1985. Truly, this ban is unnecessary and outdated. Donated blood is screened thoroughly between the time it is donated and when it is used for medical procedures. Technology easily helps us catch any tainted blood before it can be given to someone in need.
I have begun to reach out to my Congresspersons and various gay rights organizations. With President Obama in the White House, we have an amazing chance to end a moronic and discriminatory policy. Two thousand twelve is a watershed year for the gay rights movement. Let us also make this the year.
Scott Galvin has served on the NorthBeing both LGBT and Jewish is to be twice blessed, say Christie Balka and Andy Rose, and I believe them, although I have to admit that there are days when—as Woody Allen might quip—it doubles my chances of getting beat up in the schoolyard. Growing up Jewish taught me many lessons about self-esteem, taking comfort in my minority community, and accepting the fact that there really were people out there who hated me, and learning how to handle that.
Studying Jewish history, I learned much about Christian and Muslim Europe and what we now call the Middle East.
“Muslim Europe?†you ask. Yes: before the Christians were in Spain, the Muslims held the Iberian Peninsula, and no: they didn’t leave willingly. Not only might this tidbit win you a prize on a game show, it might also help you keep your head on your shoulders—and the rest of your body reasonably intact—when you have a runin with the aforementioned people who hate you. Like any other skill, it needs to be developed, which is what being Jewish did for me when I came out as a lesbian.
Another thing being Jewish taught me was an appreciation of time and history.
Jews regularly talk about how things were a thousand years ago, mostly in conjunction with holiday celebrations.
Moses and the Egyptians, Esther and the Persians, Judah Maccabee and the Romans: it could have been yesterday from the easy way these names fall off our tongues. So in Jewish time, the dawn of LGBT rights happened an hour ago.
It used to be that mainstream Jewish institutions did not welcome LGBT Jews. While there was less of the “burn in hell†variety of condemnation, we were lumped together with alcoholics, drug addicts, thieves, and other sorts of ne’er-do wells. In other words, it wasn’t something that Jews “did.†Regarding the Jewish Orthodox folks who did condemn us, I just didn’t accept their authority over my life. Coming out, I met a whole bunch of Jews who indeed did “do†gay, and during those heady times we relished how our parents had prepared us to be successful in a world eager to see us fail.
How times have changed! LGBT folks are welcome members of almost all synagogues in the U.S. For the most part, it’s a non-issue, except for programming social events and being asked if an LGBT speed-dating casino night might be successful. Lesbian and gay Jewish couples regularly have their unions blessed in a religious ceremony at their synagogue, and get married, if state law permits.
True, it’s sometimes downright dangerous being gay, especially if you’re a young person growing up in a difficult environment, but it’s not easy being Jewish either: and who told you it was going to be easy anyway? Unfortunately too many people get the message that life should be easy, and when it’s not, they figuratively sit back on their tuchas. Better I think to teach that life is hard, and here are the many ways you can navigate it.
Most of the members of my congregation have done a magnificent job of navigating through their lives, sometimes to the point of claiming that there is no longer a need for an LGBT directed synagogue. True for them, perhaps, but certainly not for the many young folks coming up and needing a place to call their own, or the adults coming out after a lifetime of living as a straight person and not knowing where to turn for community or advice. So, until the world is perfected, Etz Chaim intends to continue our mission of service to the community, however you may identify yourself.
Â
Rabbi Noah Kitty grew up in Philadelphia and graduated from the Reconstructionist Rabbinical College in 1994. She is the Executive Director of Congregation Etz Chaim in Wilton Manors, and looks forward to serving on the Women In Networking (WIN) Board. ]]>It’s tax season, and once again gay married couples are caught between the truth and the law.
Each year, the federal government demands thousands of gay married couples sign an IRS Form 1040 with this stern warning. “Under penalties of perjury, I declare that I have examined this return and accompanying schedules and statements, and to the best of my knowledge and belief, they are true and complete.â€
But how do you answer in good conscience when the IRS tells you to lie? The IRS, citing the federal Defense of Marriage Act (DOMA), demands gay couples deny our husbands and wives, and indicate our marital status as “single.â€
The IRS makes this demand despite the fact numerous courts have found DOMA to be unconstitutional, and the Department of Justice has stopped defending its key provisions.
Those of us who are married should be able to indicate our marital status honestly when filling out our tax return.
Currently, there are more than 1,000 legal protections afforded to heterosexuals that are considered inapplicable to the lesbian-gay-bisexual-transgender (LGBT) community. Many of these significantly impact finances (real estate, inheritance and health coverage, to name a few), but it is each year, on April 15, that all gay married couples come face to face with the inequities and indignity of having our families denied.
As more and more gay people get legally married in the U.S. or abroad, many married gay couples throughout the country are refusing to identify as “single.†Quietly, from California to New York, from Alaska to Florida, couples are refusing to deny their spouses and are willing to take the risks of entering legally murky territory to take a stand.
A website called RefuseToLie.org has become a gathering place for gay couples to share their stories and for others to speak out in solidarity. While many post they have chosen to file as married, the site also provides tax tips for those who wish to protest but don’t want to risk running afoul of the IRS.
Research shows gay people, on average, pay nearly $500,000 more over a lifetime due to discriminatory laws and practices. A recent CNNMoney study concluded same-sex couples are paying as much as $6,000 more in annual federal income taxes than other married couples, even in states that recognize their unions.
For example, married couples filing jointly who sell a home can exclude from taxation up to $500,000 of the income received. Gay couples are only allowed to exclude $250,000, the same as single filers.
Given these disparities, legalized bigotry has certainly cost many gay families the home they dream of in a safer neighborhood, a college education for their children, or the start-up money for a business.
My wife and I will once again file as married. We got married in Vermont, surrounded by 80 of our friends and family at the Burlington Quaker Meeting House. We committed, in front of our loved ones and duly authorized representatives of the state of Vermont, to love, cherish, and protect each other for the rest of our lives. It would be both dishonest and deeply humiliating to now disavow each other of our marriage and declare ourselves single on our tax form.
We have an 11-month-old son, and we know it is our actions that will teach him more than just our words. How can we raise him to be honest and have integrity in his interactions with other people if we fill out a form that denies our existence as a family?
Nadine Smith is the executive director of Equality Florida.
She can be reached at Nadine@eqfl.org.
]]>We have all been out on a Thursday night: the Drive comes alive, it’s almost the weekend, and it’s time to let your hair down. You pull into the vast parking lot and rush in to meet your friends. You have a couple of drinks, socialize, and when you look out over the car park and see all the guys around, you can’t help but think “wow, how lucky am I to live in–or at the very least visit–Greater Fort Lauderdale and to have somewhere like The Shoppes of Wilton Manors to use as a base!†Well, yes you are, if you aren’t towed.
The signs are posted: the parking spaces in The Shoppes are reserved for patrons of the businesses. A bit extreme, as it is the center of Wilton Manors life, but ok, fair enough. Many of the establishments on and off the Drive have their own reserved- for-valet parking spaces. The signs are clear: you can’t leave your car unattended unless you are patronizing one of the businesses. What they don’t tell you is if you break the rules, you will be sent somewhere in which you could be killed.
You can imagine my utter shock to find that after a great evening catching up with friends, our car had been towed. There was no help or explanation offered, other than to “call the number on the sign,†which we did. Although told over the phone that we needed to pay to pick it up, at no point was it mentioned that they only accept cash- -do most people routinely walk around with over $100 in cash on them?
I know it sounds awfully dramatic, but if you get towed, say “goodbye†to the safety of Wilton Manors, to the ability to be yourself, and to feel safe and secure. In fact, say “hello†to the worst district in Fort Lauderdale, the area around 1800 West Sunrise Blvd., which is where your car will be towed. West Sunrise Blvd. is notorious for a few things: it is where a spring breaker last month was beaten to within an inch of his life for possession of his laptop; it also, as of last month, has the area’s highest rate of homicides; and it is where I found myself last Thursday night.
We took a cab to the tow yard, and immediately knew we were in the wrong neighborhood. Since there was no ATM nearby, we walked through what I can only describe as a frightening, dangerous area to a gas station where we got cash.
On our walk back–nervous, frightened and trying to be as aware as possible–a mugger snatched my partner’s $2,000 gold chain from his neck. The police officer who took our report was very clear that no one should ever be in that area at night, under any circumstances. We learned that the hard way.
I couldn’t agree more with parking rules: you park only where you visit. But if you break that rule, should you be forced to take your life into your hands? Many would argue to go during the day to pick up your car if it’s towed, but it was implied to us they would impose extra charges for holding it overnight.
For gay men, one benefit of living in or visiting Wilton Manors is the element of safety: the towing policy violates that.
There is an empty lot behind The Shoppes with some 30-odd spaces: would it not make more sense to tow the cars back there, and simply raise the towing fee?
There would be people who argue the fee will be too high, but right now the fee could end up costing you your life. Attention has been called to the towing policy before, but having experienced firsthand the unbridled danger of what it means to be towed action must now be taken—before someone in the community gets hurt or killed.
Alex Vaughn is the former Editor-in- Chief of the Florida Agenda.
Editor’s Note: At press time, Rivercrest Realty Investors, the owners of The Shoppes of Wilton Manors, have stopped utilizing the services of EMS Towing.
]]>FORT LAUDERDALE – The Angry Left doesn’t have conservative commentator and author Andrew Breitbart to kick around anymore. I’m sorry to admit I never considered the legendary blogger a hero until he was gone. But his absence hit me and the country with a deafening thud.
Breitbart dedicated himself to the cause of bringing to light the hypocrisy and vulgarity of the so-called “progressive†left.
He wasn’t about to let them get away with pretending to be open-minded and accepting of individuality. He knew the dark history of the Left and its members’ penchant for the politics of division. Thanks to his work, many of us know the truth, too.
Sometimes Breitbart got it wrong when breaking a story. With his flair for the dramatic, he would occasionally overplay a nugget of truth as though he had the scoop of the century. But along the way, he did uncover some doozies and got Americans talking about some previously unspoken political truths. Beyond muckraking, he used his larger-than-life personality to rally unlikely groups to the conservative brotherhood.
Breitbart was a man of inclusion. He served on the advisory council of the gay Republican group GOProud and was known to have many gay, liberal, and minority friends. While this fact rarely caused right wing outrage, it did spark a meltdown on the left.
The rumor mill spat vile epithets at Breitbart, accusing him of being a closeted gay, predicting that he would die of AIDS, rot in hell, etc. In his lighthearted fashion, Andrew would re-tweet the messages as an homage to and reminder of the true nature of the left.
Breitbart urged conservatives from all walks of life to keep focused on opposing the radical (read: entire) Left, rather than each other. At a recent gathering of the Conservative Political Action Conference (CPAC), he admonished the GOP faithful to rise above personal differences for the urgent cause of defeating the political opposition.
“The Republican Party and the conservative movement is not what ABC and CBS puts up on the screen,†Breitbart announced. “They try to portray you in the worst possible light. And when I walk through CPAC or I travel through the United States and I meet people in the Tea Party who care–black, white, gay, and straight–anyone who’s willing to stand next to me to fight the progressive Left, I will be in that bunker.
And if you’re not in that bunker because you’re not satisfied with this candidate, [then] more than shame on you. You’re on the other side.â€
In some strange way, Breitbart made it “cool,†or at least acceptable to be conservative.
Was he a gay hero? For those of us who want to see both parties fighting for inclusion and equality, maybe he should have been. The truth is that the world at large was a much, much better place with him in it.
]]>Rocky Bowell – Manager of Pride Factory
I’m thankful for the continued success of Pride Factory especially during these bad economic times.
Â
Â
Julie Pohlig – Retired
I’m thankful for my friends, family and my health.
Â
Â
Â
Scott M. –
Student Manager
I’m thankful for my friends, family and having a job in this horrible economy.
Â
Â
Â
Dale Madison –
Fundraising Coordinator for Poverello
I am so thankful for my true friends who have stood by me through all of the trials and tribulations.
Â
Â
Joe McConnell – Retired
I just lost my partner and I’m thankful for the 35 years we’ve had together.
Â
Â
Â
Â
Tom Villano –
Retired Teacher
I’m very thankful for my good and loving partner and two daughters. I’m also thankful to have a comfortable lifestyle here in Wilton Manors.
Â
Â
Â
Bradley James –
Seeking Employment
I’m thankful to be alive and breathing.
Â
Â
Â
Wolf Gann –
Manager at CopyThis
I am thankful for seeing the many blessings life provides every day. I’m thankful life’s many distractions and dark hours can’t blind the good in humanity. Most of all, I’m thankful to the many friends, workers and business owners in Wilton Manors who have shown me true kindness, friendship and love.
Â
Albert Cortes –
Floral Designer
In these hard times, we often wonder what is there to be thankful for
? Remember that there are people worse off than you and may need a favor. Do that favor for someone that needs it. It brings us closer together and gives us yet another thing to be thankful for.
Â
Â
Â
Albert Taylor –Health Coordinator
I am thankful for good health and reaching my goals in the year 2011. I am thankful for the new friendships and new love this Thanksgiving. I am very proud to be part of the Wilton Manors community and hope everyone has a wonderful holiday season.
Â
Â
Robert Cieslak, Realtor Saved!This movie deals with coming out and coming of age. In a way, it really hits home. I spent the entire movie laughing at the homophobic references and cried with the touching message at the end.
Â
Â
Â
Vincent P. Cicenia, Retired Writer
The Single Man – It reflects my life during my younger gay years. I also like Colin Firth.
Â
Â
Â
Mike Rivers, Adult Film Actor
Latter Days – My favorite PG13 movie. It was very moving and emotional. Of course, I need to promote myself. For an adult film, I loved “Something’s Cum Up.†It was my first dud I’ve done with the talented and amazing Chi Chi LaRue.
Â
Â
Â
Â
Con Arvello, Dispatcher
Priscilla, Queen of the Desert – All the music and colorful costumes, the scenes in the Australian outback and lastly, the Abba tunes..
Â
Â
Â
Â
Bruce Bogan, Owner, CopyThis
The Big Gay Musical – Very entertaining musical about life, love and relationships, A love story that can happen – funny, serious, touching and make-believe all in one.